4 THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT AN OVERLAY

Admin • May 11, 2018
Shingles

An overlay is a roofing process where a new layer of shingles is applied on top of your existing layer of shingles. This project is one way to prolong the life of your roof without a complete roof replacement. That said, an overlay only works under certain conditions. Read on to learn about some advantages and drawbacks of this method.

1. Roof Decking Must Be Strong Enough

For an overlay to work, your roof still needs to be in relatively good shape. Specifically, your roof decking has to be strong enough to support the weight of an overlay.

The roof decking is the layer that all the other roofing materials go on top of. Plywood is the most common residential roof decking material.

If the roof deck is in poor condition, the new roof may fail. For example, a rotting roof deck will not be able to support the weight of an overlay and could result in your roof collapsing down the line.

2. Existing Shingles Need to Be in Good Shape

Next, for an overlay to work, your shingles also need to be in decent shape. If your shingles are cracked, breaking down, and missing, an overlay is not a good idea. That’s because shingles with extensive damage are a sign of that your roof has water damage under the shingles.


Water damage needs to be dealt with directly, which is why a tear-off is best if the quality of your shingles is greatly compromised. If the shingles are old but still providing adequate coverage, then an overlay will work.

3. Most Roofs Can Only Support Two Layers of Shingles

Most roofs can only support a couple of layers of shingles. Shingles are really heavy, and your roof decking is only designed to support so much weight. When your roof starts to get too heavy, the decking and tresses under your roof could become compromised and damaged.


Additionally, in many areas, building regulations dictate how many layers of shingles your roof is allowed to have. In most areas, building codes only permit two layers of shingles on your roof, although some areas allow three layers of shingles.


If you already have two layers of shingles on your roof, it may be time for a tear-off instead of putting an additional layer of shingles on your roof. If you only have one layer of shingles on your roof, an additional layer should comply with local building codes.

4. Overlays Can Save You a Significant Amount of Money

Finally, a roofing overlay instead of a tear-off can save you a significant amount of money. With an overlay, you are just paying for shingles, nails, and the labor to put the shingles on your roof.


When you have a tear-off performed on your roof, you pay for the labor to remove the old roofing materials. You also have to pay for the disposal of the old roofing materials.


Additionally, you have to pay for a lot more materials when you have your roof completely replaced. You have to pay for new underlayment, as well as potentially new decking.


If you know that your roof needs to be replaced but you don't have a big budget, an overlay could save you some money. However, it won’t last as long as completely replacing your roof.


If you are considering an overlay instead of a tear-off for your roof, have our team at Whittle's Roofing Co., Inc., come out and inspect your roof. We can let you know if your roof is in the right condition for an overlay and help you explore affordable roofing replacement solutions.

July 30, 2026
Which roofing material can really stand up to Gainesville, FL's punishing combination of high humidity, intense summer heat, torrential afternoon storms, and real hurricane-season wind risk? A material that holds up fine in a dry climate can fail quickly here. In this article, we break down the three most common options for Gainesville homeowners: composite shingles, metal roofing, and flat/TPO systems.
July 30, 2026
Not sure how to pick the right roofer in Gainesville, FL? Florida's roofing industry is regulated, and Alachua County's heavy seasonal rain and intense humidity mean your roof faces real stress year-round. In this article, we'll show you how to vet a licensed contractor and hire with confidence.
construction worker installing asphalt shingles on a roof while wearing a safety harness.
July 24, 2026
Hire a trusted local roofer in Gainesville, FL, with Whittle's Roofing Co. Inc. Get code-compliant, climate-smart roofing. Request a free estimate today.
A professional roofer using a power drill to perform a roof leak repair on a metal rooftop.
April 3, 2026
Stop roof damage now! Whittle’s Roofing Co., Inc. offers rapid repair for roof leaks in Gainesville, FL. Call (352) 472-2410 to protect your home and save!
A roofer installing tiles at sunset, showcasing full roofing services with professional care.
February 27, 2026
Discover full roofing services in Gainesville, FL, with Whittles Roofing Co., Inc. Contact (352) 472-2410 for expert solutions from repair to installation.
A close-up of a roofer using a pneumatic nail gun to install tiles on a roof.
January 29, 2026
Learn the signs your home needs residential roofing repair in Gainesville, FL. Call Whittle’s Roofing Co., Inc. at (352) 472-2410 for inspections today!
Roofer in red shirt and green overalls repairing brown shingle roof near open skylight window.
October 13, 2025
Looking for a trusted residential roofer in Gainesville, FL? P Whittle’s Roofing offers expert repair and replacement. Visit our website today!
Neat Roofing of A House — Gainesville, FL — Whittle’s Roofing Co. Inc
By Admin February 10, 2021
Discover why fiberglass shingles win—lighter, moisture- and fire-resistant, eco-friendly. Learn more from Whittle’s Roofing Co Inc in Gainesville & Newberry FL.
Roofing Construction — Gainesville, FL — Whittle’s Roofing Co. Inc
By Admin January 20, 2021
Roof condensation isn’t harmless—learn what causes it and how Whittle’s Roofing Co Inc in Gainesville & Newberry FL can help prevent damage. Read now.
See why metal roofs last decades, resist fire and weather, and help lower bills—Whittle’s Roofing Co
By Admin January 4, 2021
If you are about to replace an old roof, then metal might be the right choice for you. Discover seven reasons to invest in a metal roof.